NationalRestricting TV time, Temple visits to Daughter-in-Law 'Not Cruelty': Bombay HC

Date:

Restricting TV time, Temple visits to Daughter-in-Law ‘Not Cruelty’: Bombay HC

The Bombay High Court (HC)‘s Aurangabad Bench has overturned a family’s conviction in a domestic cruelty case, ruling that preventing a woman from watching television, visiting temples, or meeting neighbours does not constitute “severe cruelty” under Section 498A of the Indian Penal Code (IPC).

Here’s what Bombay HC said:

Justice Abhay S Waghwase, presiding over the case, determined that these restrictions, which included making the woman sleep on a carpet, fell within the realm of domestic affairs rather than meeting the threshold for physical and mental cruelty.

The case stemmed from allegations that led to the woman’s death by suicide on May 1, 2002. Her family had accused her husband and in-laws of cruel treatment, including forcing her to fetch water at midnight. However, the defence successfully argued that water supply began at that hour in their village, making the 1:30 AM water collection routine for all households.

In its ruling, the Bombay HC also highlighted significant gaps in the prosecution’s case. “There is a gap of almost two months since the deceased, complainant and witnesses met each other,” the court noted. “They (mother, uncle and aunt of deceased) have admitted that, there was no communication from deceased either written or oral, she has not conveyed that there were any instances of cruelty in proximity to suicide.”

No evidence of cruelty, says Bombay HC

The judgment further emphasized the lack of evidence connecting any alleged cruelty to the woman’s death: “There is no evidence to show that at that relevant point or any proximity to the suicide, there was any demand, cruelty or mal-treatment to connect them with the suicidal death. What triggered the suicide has remained a mystery.”

This ruling effectively overturns the trial court’s earlier conviction of the husband and his family members, establishing a precedent for what constitutes “severe” cruelty under Section 498A of the IPC in domestic dispute cases.

Share post:

Popular

More like this
Related

Army Personnel Taken into Custody in Punjab for Suspected ISI Espionage

A significant breakthrough has emerged in the Punjab Police’s...

One Crore Jobs on the Horizon as Bihar Unveils Long-Term Economic Strategy

As the State Assembly elections draw near, Bihar Chief...

Bihar Forms Special Unit to Track and Monitor Contract Killers

Following the assassination of industrialist Gopal Khemka—allegedly carried out...

Nitish Kumar Urges Swift Action on Teacher Hiring Process by Education Department

Bihar Chief Minister Nitish Kumar has directed the...